Hamilton Ohio Employee Hits IUOE Union Bosses with Federal First Amendment Lawsuit Challenging Deceptive Forced Fee Scheme
Janus v. AFSCME Supreme Court decision clearly forbids forced union fees for public employees, but IUOE bosses try to pass them off as âagreement administration feesâ
Cincinnati, OH (December 14, 2020) â With free legal aid from National Right to Work Foundation staff attorneys, City of Hamilton employee Timothy Crane is suing International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE) Local 20 union officials and the City of Hamilton for seizing a compulsory fee from his paycheck in violation of his First Amendment rights. His complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, contends that union bosses are infringing on his rights under the Janus v. AFSCME decision by forcing him to pay a so-called âagreement administration feeâ equal to more than 90 percent of full union dues as a condition of his employment.
In the 2018 Foundation-won Janus decision, the High Court ruled that no public worker can be forced to pay union dues or fees as a condition of getting or keeping a job. The Court also held that union dues or fees can only be deducted from a public employeeâs paycheck if that employee clearly and affirmatively waives his or her right not to pay. Justice Alito wrote for the Court majority that âsuch a waiver cannot be presumedâ by union or state officials.
Crane works for the City of Hamilton. He sent letters to IUOE union officials in both August and September of this year attempting to exercise his First Amendment Janus right to end dues deductions from his paycheck. After sending these two letters, he discovered that an âagreement administration feeâ was now being taken from his pay by the City at the behest of IUOE union bosses.
Craneâs lawsuit points out that the most recent contract between the City of Hamilton and IUOE Local 20 requires employees who have revoked their dues deduction authorizations to pay compulsory agreement administration fees. The complaint contends that this fee is just a so-called âagency feeâ â compulsory union payments charged to employees who refrain from formal union membership that were definitively outlawed by the Janus v. AFSCME decision â masquerading under a different name.
The suit urges the District Court to declare it unconstitutional for IUOE Local 20 and the City of Hamilton to force him to pay this compulsory union fee. Craneâs lawsuit also seeks a refund of all money that the union illegally took from his paycheck under the unconstitutional arrangement.
Since Janus was handed down by the Supreme Court, Foundation staff attorneys have already won favorable settlements in four cases for Buckeye State public workers who have challenged illegal union-created restrictions on the exercise of Janus First Amendment rights. In a July settlement in a class-action lawsuit filed by four state workers, nearly 30,000 Ohio public employees were freed from an âescape periodâ scheme imposed by Ohio Civil Service Employees Association (OCSEA) union chiefs, which limited to just a handful of days every few years the time in which a public employee could exercise his or her Janus rights.
âIUOE bosses, who may have thought they were going to trick employees into funding their agenda against their will with this blatantly unconstitutional scheme, have now been caught red-handed,â commented National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. âRank-and-file workers like Mr. Crane now see that IUOE officials are far more interested in keeping hard-earned employee cash flowing into their coffers than in respecting the First Amendment rights of the workers they claim to represent.â
Mix continued: âThe string of Foundation victories for independent-minded Buckeye State employees who just want to exercise their First Amendment rights is not going to end here.â
Labor Board to Prosecute IUOE Union Officials for Restricting Rieth-Riley Workersâ Resignations and Dues Revocations
Workers already receiving $1,000+ refunds, Labor Board says that union officials used illegal barriers to prevent workers from ending dues payments
Detroit, MI (December 10, 2020) â In response to federal charges filed by three employees of Rieth-Riley Construction Company, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) Region 7 in Detroit has just hit the International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE) Local 324 union with a second consolidated complaint for using unlawful resignation and revocation requirements to trap employees in unwanted membership and dues payments. The three employees are receiving free legal aid from the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation.
Absent settlement, the case will now go before an NLRB Administrative Law Judge. NLRB Region 7âs complaint comes as IUOE union bosses appear to be hurriedly refunding illegally-seized dues to workers, possibly to avoid further litigation on the issue. While the NLRB case to prosecute the union continues, some workers who had ended their memberships as early as 2019 are already reporting receiving checks from the union of up to four-figure sums, apparently to refund illegally-seized money, most likely in response to the Foundation-backed litigation.
The NLRB complaint consolidates the cases of Rieth-Riley employees Jesse London, Rob Nevins, and John Shipkosky, who each charged the union this year with ignoring their letters exercising their right to resign from the union and to stop any dues deductions. The complaint specifically says that union officials illegally required dues authorization revocations to be submitted by registered or certified mail, and additionally failed to inform employees that ârevocation is effective at any time upon the expiration ofâ the unionâs monopoly bargaining contract.
According to the complaint, the unionâs enforcement of these restrictions violated their and their coworkersâ right to refrain from union activities guaranteed by the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). The complaint now seeks a ruling from an NLRB Administrative Law Judge that will order union officials to â[m]ake whole any affected employees, for any financial lossâ that resulted from the unionâs illegal dues deduction scheme.
NLRB Region 7âs consolidated complaint also comes just weeks after Rieth-Riley employees submitted an emergency appeal in support of their effort to vote IUOE Local 324 bosses out of their workplace. They are challenging Region 7âs November 9 decision to suppress the ballots just hours before they were scheduled to be tallied, due to unverified charges IUOE bosses made against Rieth-Riley management. Foundation attorneys argue in the workersâ appeal that Region 7âs decision ignores new NLRB rules that require that employee votes be counted before such charges are dealt with.
âOperating Engineers union bosses were caught red-handed illegally seizing dues from Rieth-Riley workers in violation of their rights. Returning those ill-gotten funds is just the first step to fully vindicate the rights of IUOEâs victims,â commented National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. âFoundation staff attorneys are proud to stand with the hardworking men and women of Rieth-Riley, including in their effort to have their votes counted to free themselves from unwanted union so-called ârepresentation.ââ
Federal Appeals Court to Hear United Airlines Workerâs Lawsuit Challenging Forced Union Dues âOpt-Outâ Scheme
Foundation attorneys argue IAM union opt-out requirement to escape payment for union officialsâ political activities violates Supreme Courtâs Janus precedent
New Orleans, LA (December 9, 2020) â Today the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit will hear arguments in United Airlines fleet service employee Arthur Baisleyâs class action lawsuit against the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers (IAM) union. The case, which Baisley filed with free legal aid from the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, challenges the requirement that employees opt out during a brief âwindow periodâ in many instances or else be required to pay for union officialsâ political and ideological activities.
Baisleyâs attorneys will argue the opt-out scheme violates workersâ rights under the Railway Labor Act (RLA), and the First Amendment under the standard laid out in the landmark 2018 Supreme Court Janus v. AFSCME decision. They contend that, under Janus and the 2012 Knox v. SEIU Supreme Court case â both of which were argued at the High Court by National Right to Work Foundation staff attorneys â no union dues or fees can be charged beyond the maximum that can legally be required without a workerâs affirmative consent.
The employee, Arthur Baisley, is not a member of the IAM but is still forced to pay union fees despite being based in the Right to Work state of Texas. The Railway Labor Act pre-empts state Right to Work protections which make union membership and financial support strictly voluntary. However, under longstanding law, even without Right to Work protections nonmembers cannot be required to fund a unionâs ideological activities such as lobbying and politics.
The lawsuit challenges the burdensome procedure IAM union officials created for workers seeking to exercise their right not to fund the ânonchargableâ activities. The complaint lays out the convoluted union boss-created process that workers must jump through just to prevent dues from being taken in violation of their First Amendment rights.
Baisleyâs experience with these requirements demonstrates how the opt-out procedure is used to violate workersâ rights by forcing them to pay for union politics without their consent. Even though he sent a letter to IAM agents in November 2018 objecting to funding all union political activities, union officials only accepted his objection for 2019, and told Baisley he had to renew his objection to full dues and fees the next year or else be charged for full union dues.
The complaint challenges this union-created policy on the grounds that it ârequire[s] employees to opt-out of paying union fees that they have no legal obligation to payâ and thus breaches workersâ First Amendment rights. The complaint also alleges that the IAMâs âopt-out requirementâ violates the RLA, which governs labor in the air and rail industries and âprotects the right of employees to âjoin, organize, or assist in organizingâ a union of their choice as well as the right to refrain from any of those activities.â
The class action lawsuit asks the court to strike down the op-out requirement not only as it is applied to Baisley, but also for his coworkers whose rights are similarly restricted by the IAMâs illegal policy. Union officials would then be required to get nonmember workers to give affirmative consent to paying for union boss activities beyond what nonmember workers can legally be required to subsidize under the RLA.
âFor too long union bosses have enforced deliberately complicated opt-out requirements with the aim of trapping workers into paying for union boss politics despite the fact that, as nonmembers, they have already chosen not to affiliate with the union,â said National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. âThe Supreme Court ruled in the Foundation-won Janus v. AFSCME case that government unions must get consent before forcing public sector employees to fund a union because all speech directed at the government is inherently political.â
âThis case seeks to apply the same legal standard to workers like Mr. Baisley who are subjected to mandatory union payments under the Railway Labor Act by requiring union officials to get workers to opt in to the portion of dues that the union already admits it spends on ideological and political activities,â added Mix.
Judge Rules for ABC Cameraman in Case against NABET Union Officials Who Seized Illegal Dues from His Paycheck
Union bosses ignored his attempts to exercise his rights, now must refund all illegally taken money
Portland, OR (December 7, 2020) â Portland-area ABC cameraman Jeremy Brown has just won a decision in his case charging National Association of Broadcast Employees and Technicians (NABET-CWA) Local 51 union officials with demanding and seizing illegal dues from him and for ignoring his multiple attempts to exercise his right to refrain from union membership and not pay for union political activities. He is represented at the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) by National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation staff attorneys.
A December 3 ruling by an NLRB Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) found that NABET union bosses have, since April 2019, breached federal labor law by violating Brownâs rights under the Foundation-won CWA v. Beck Supreme Court decision. Beck stipulates that union bosses can only compel employees, like Brown, who have objected to formal union membership to pay for specific, limited costs directly related to the unionâs bargaining functions. An employee cannot be required to pay for the unionâs political, lobbying and other non-bargaining expenditures. Beck also requires union officials to provide such employees an independent audit of the unionâs financial breakdown and the process by which they calculate the reduced fee amount, among other disclosures.
According to the ALJâs decision, Brown resumed work with ABC in 2016 after periods of intermittent hire since 1999, at no point joining the union. A new president, Carrie Biggs-Adams, took over the NABET union in the workplace in late 2018 and sent Brown a series of letters in early 2019 which claimed that, as a condition of employment, he had to pay nearly $10,000 dollars in initiation fees and âback agency dues.â
Because Brown works primarily in states without Right to Work protections, which make union membership and financial support voluntary, he can be required to pay a fee to the union as a condition of employment.
Brown, who according to the ALJâs decision was unaware until 2019 that he was under the NABET unionâs bargaining power, emailed Biggs-Adams in April 2019 asking for âclarificationâ regarding the fee demands and also exercised his Beck rights by objecting âto the collection and expenditure by the union of a fee for any purpose other thanâ certain bargaining activities. The decision also recounts that Brown informed Biggs-Adams that he filled out an application for formal NABET membership (which included an authorization for full dues deductions from his paycheck), but did so under duress, believing that he would be fired if he did not agree to pay dues.
Several follow-ups by Brown were not acknowledged by Biggs-Adams. According to the ALJâs ruling, she âbelieved Local 51 had no obligation to do so because Beck objectionsâ are handled only by the unionâs national headquarters under NABET rules. Biggs-Adams never told Brown that his Beck objection was misdirected nor provided any of the disclosures Beck requires under prior Board decisions, and the union never reduced his fee amount in accordance with Beck.
The ALJâs decision holds that the NABET Local 51 union violated Brownâs rights under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) through its officialsâ omissions and the failure to reduce his dues. The ALJ orders that NABET Local 51 provide Brown with âa good faith determination of the reduced dues and fees objectors must pay,â âreimburse Brown for all dues and fees collectedâ beyond what is required by Beck with interest, and post notices informing the employees in Brownâs workplace of the decision.
âNABET union bosses flat out ignored multiple attempts by Mr. Brown to exercise his Beck rights, all the while stuffing their coffers with well over the limit of cash that they could legally demand from him,â commented National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. âWhile this decision vindicated Mr. Brownâs legal rights, it also demonstrates why every American worker deserves the protection of a Right to Work law to shield them from union boss threats to pay up or be fired.â
Chicago Mental Health Counselor Files Federal Class Action Suit Against SEIU for Dues Seizures in Violation of First Amendment
Lawsuit seeks to end scheme that blocks University of Illinois workers from exercising constitutional right to stop union dues deductions
Chicago, IL (December 7, 2020)Â â With free legal representation from National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation staff attorneys, Johnathan Shepard, a mental health counselor working for the University of Illinois Hospital & Health Sciences System (UI Health), has filed a federal class-action civil rights lawsuit against Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 73 and the Universityâs Board of Trustees.
The suit challenges Local 73 union officialsâ policy enforced by the University that blocks University employees from exercising their First Amendment right to stop payments to the union outside of a fifteen-day annual âescape period.â The lawsuit seeks refunds of all dues seized as a result of the unconstitutional policy.
The complaint states that SEIU officials and the University of Illinois are breaching the First Amendment protections recognized in the 2018 Janus v. AFSCME U.S. Supreme Court decision. In Janus, then-Illinois state employee Mark Janus was represented before the Supreme Court by William Messenger, the veteran Foundation attorney who is also handling Shepardâs case.
In its ruling in Janus, the High Court struck down mandatory union fees as violating the First Amendment rights of government employees. The Court ruled that any union dues taken without a government workerâs affirmative consent violates the First Amendment, and that these rights cannot be restricted absent a clear and knowing waiver by employees of their First Amendment rights.
The lawsuit explains that Shepard sent a letter to SEIU officials exercising his right under Janus to resign union membership and cut off all dues payments during a strike ordered by SEIU union bosses. According to the complaint, SEIU officials confirmed receipt of the letter but said that they would continue to seize dues from Shepardâs paycheck unless he sends another revocation letter during an annual fifteen-day escape period that does not open until July 2021.
SEIU and the University of Illinoisâ escape period policy effectively prohibits employees from exercising their First Amendment rights under Janus for 350 days of the year (351 during leap years). Shepard contends in his lawsuit that SEIU and the University of Illinois violate the First Amendment by seizing payments for union speech from employees who resign their union membership and object to dues deductions outside of this short escape period. The complaint asks the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois to order the SEIU and the University to stop enforcing the unconstitutional escape period and to order SEIU to refund to employees the dues it has unlawfully seized from them over their objections.
âOnce again, SEIU officials are violating the First Amendment Janus rights of workers they claim to represent just so they can keep dues money rolling into their unionâs coffers,â observed National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. âThe Foundation is proud to stand with Mr. Shepard, and will continue to defend all healthcare employees who simply want to serve their patients without being forced to subsidize union activities.â
NLRB Moves to Prosecute Yotel Boston and UNITE HERE for Violating Workersâ Rights in Coercive âCard Checkâ Unionization
Labor Board complaint says hotel officials illegally assisted union boss organizing drive used to impose union monopoly ârepresentationâ on housekeepers
Boston, MA (December 1, 2020)Â â Yesterday the Acting Boston Regional Director of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) issued a complaint against the Yotel Hotel and the UNITE HERE Local 26 union after the hotel illegally assisted union officials with foisting the union on workers. Housekeepers Cindy J. Alarcon Vasquez, Lady Laura Javier, Yesica Perez Barrios, and Danela Guzman filed unfair labor practice charges with the Board in December of 2019 with free legal assistance from National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation staff attorneys.
The charges, which resulted in todayâs complaint, say the hotel illegally assisted the unionâs coercive âcard checkâ drive, during which employees were pressured by union operatives into signing union cards. These cards were later counted as âvotes,â and were used to bypass a secret ballot election that would have determined whether the workers actually support union representation.
The NLRB has long held that an employer taints employeesâ efforts to remove a union if it gives those employees support such as a list of bargaining unit employees or use of company resources. The workerâs attorneys here argue that Yotel Boston similarly tainted the unionâs organizing campaign by providing assistance to UNITE HERE union organizers that amounted to more than permitted âministerial aid.â
Such assistance, while it is presumed to taint the results of decertification votes, has often been overlooked by the Board when the assistance benefits union officials in their efforts to gain monopoly representation powers over rank-and-file workers.
By issuing the complaint, the NLRB is finally applying the standard equally no matter whether the assistance is used to impose or remove union monopoly representation. Further, the complaint finds that Yotel violated the law when they recognized UNITE HERE as the workersâ monopoly representative as a result of the illegal assistance.
The case is not the first in which the NLRB has addressed this double standard. In July NLRB Region 19 issued a similar complaint in another case involving a hotel worker whose employer illegally assisted UNITE HERE Local 8 union officials in its card check drive at Embassy Suites in Seattle. There the NLRB also agreed that the employer had provided more than âministerial aid,â and therefore UNITE HERE officials âdid not represent an uncoerced majority of the unit.â
âThe NLRB is finally addressing the double standard that for too long has favored union bosses in their coercive card check unionization drives,â said National Right to Work Foundation President Mark Mix. âUnion bosses pressure workers and get illegal assistance from employers to impose their so-called representation on workers, but they cry foul when that same assistance is given to workers attempting to remove unwanted forced representation.â
âWith these complaints against UNITE-HERE union bosses the Board is correctly finding that what qualifies as more than âministerial assistance and support,â and thus violates the National Labor Relations Act, cannot depend on whether the employer is helping outside union organizers impose unionization on workers or is assisting workers in exercising their right to remove an unwanted union.â










